Peaceful Protest Over Istanbul Park Turns Violent as Police Crack Down
by TIM ARANGO and CEYLAN YEGINSU
ISTANBUL — Police officers attacked a group of peaceful demonstrators on Friday in Istanbul's Taksim Square with water cannons and tear gas, sending scores of people, protesters and tourists alike, scurrying into shops and luxury hotels and turning the center of this city into a battle zone at the height of tourist season.
The police action was the latest violent crackdown by the government against a growing protest movement challenging plans to replace a park in Taksim Square, Istanbul's equivalent of Cairo's Tahrir Square, with a replica Ottoman-era army barracks that would house a shopping mall.
But while the removal of the park, which is filled with sycamore trees and is the last significant green space in the center of Istanbul, set off the protests at the beginning of the week, the gatherings have broadened into a wider expression of anger against the heavy-handed tactics and urban development plans of the government and its leader, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan. His party, now in power a decade, is increasingly viewed by many Turks as becoming authoritarian.
Mr. Erdogan still has great support among Turkey's religious masses, but secular critics cite his government'ssweeping prosecution and intimidation of journalists as evidence of its intolerance of dissent.
Much of the anger also centers on the struggle over Istanbul's public spaces. Mr. Erdogan's government has proceeded with disputed urban development plans with little public input, while his police forces have increasingly used tear gas against peaceful protesters, resulting in scores of injuries, including the hospitalization on Friday of a Turkish lawmaker, a member of the Kurdish Party who had become a vocal participant in the protests, after he was hit by a tear gas canister.
The protest movement comes amid continued public anger at Turkey's policy of supporting the rebels in Syria, which many Turks feel has led to a violent spillover inside Turkey, including recent car bombingsin the southern city of Reyhanli, which killed dozens of people. The rising public disenchantment represents a significant political challenge to Mr. Erdogan, who is planning to run for the presidency next year and has been trying to alter the Constitution to create a more powerful presidential system.
In the early afternoon Friday, as protesters gathered and began shouting antigovernment chants, police officers in riot gear began surrounding the group, positioning vehicles that resembled tanks at the edge of the square around the protesters, who were mostly sitting.
"Taksim is ours; we are not giving it to the A.K.P.!" they chanted, referring to Mr. Erdogan's Islamist-rooted Justice and Development Party, known as the A.K.P.
As they chanted, police officers casually put on their gas masks and the operators of the tanklike vehicles aimed their big guns, which fire a mixture of water and tear gas, at the group. Then chaos erupted. Protesters and onlookers, some of them tourists, ran down side streets where shopkeepers offered sliced lemons to soothe the burning sensation of the gas, and pharmacists doled out ointments for skin burns.
"The pigs, the pigs," said Esra Yurtnac, who was crying as she sought refuge in a bakery after being gassed. "All they know is how to use gas."
She added, "They think they can silence us with force, but they won't."
Hours after the clashes with protesters, an Istanbul court on Friday ruled in favor of a petition by a local advocacy group and halted the project until parties submitted their legal arguments to court, the semiofficial Anatolian News Agency reported. The interior minister also pledged on Friday that claims of excessive force would be investigated.
The chaos followed a dawn raid on an Occupy Wall Street-style encampment in Gezi Park, near Taksim, in which the police also used tear gas to drive away protesters and later barricaded the park. In an earlier raid on the camp, on Thursday, the police set fire to some tents. The brief occupation of the park, which began after bulldozers had started to take down trees, had taken on a festival-like atmosphere, with yoga, barbecues and musical performances, while those gathered chanted, "Taksim is ours! Istanbul is ours!"
The people adorned the camp with banners expressing the rising anger at the reshaping of Istanbul's urban spaces by the government. One read, "Don't touch our neighborhood, our squares, our trees, our water, our soil, our homes, our villages, our cities and our parks."
Another referred to Mr. Erdogan and the growing number of shopping malls being built around the city. "Let all shopping malls crumble and let Tayyip get crushed by their rubble," the banner read.
In building new mosques and emphasizing Turkey's Islamic past over its Byzantine and Roman legacies, Mr. Erdogan has been referred to as a latter-day Ottoman sultan, with little regard for seeking public input on the projects. On Wednesday, the government held a groundbreaking ceremony for a third bridge over the Bosporus that is being named for an Ottoman sultan.
"It's all about superiority, and ruling over the people like sultans," said one of the protesters, Seckin Barbaros, 26, a former journalist who is now unemployed. "When were we asked what we wanted? We have three times the amount of mosques as we do schools. Yet they are building new mosques. There are eight shopping malls in the vicinity of Taksim, yet they want to build another."
In a speech earlier in the week, Mr. Erdogan dismissed the protesters and said the destruction of park would go ahead, "no matter what they do."
The anger in the streets is also a rebuke to the economic policies of the government, which have relied heavily on construction and new housing in Istanbul to power economic growth. Turkey has had a resilient economy that emerged relatively unscathed from the global financial crisis, eclipsing the performance of Europe and many other nations. But some analysts worry the government's focus on construction projects could lead to a bubble much like the one in the United States that led to the economic collapse of 2008.
Ms. Barbaros said, "What about the day when all these shopping malls will be empty like in Greece and then they will wish they never constructed them."
She added: "Where are the opera houses? The theaters? The culture and youth centers? What about those? They only choose what will bring them the most profit without considering what we need."
Another demonstrator, Seyfettin Sabaz, who is training to be a dentist, said: "Many of the Turkish public think that we are here as environmentalists to save our sycamore trees. But that's not it. We are here to stand up against those that are trying to make a profit from our land."
Around Taksim Square, the site of several other tear gas attacks on protesters this year, including one on May Day demonstrators, the chaos is taking on a sense of the familiar to shopkeepers who are becoming accustomed to offering shelter and aid to tear gas victims.
"I own a decorations shop, but for the past year it has felt like I run a shelter for gas raid victims," said Ali Yildrim, who has lived in Istanbul for 35 years. "Soon I'll be keeping lemons and medicine behind my counter."
Sebnem Arsu contributed reporting from Antakya, Turkey.
This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:
Correction: June 6, 2013
An article on Saturday about attacks by police on peaceful protesters in Istanbul misidentified the nationality of a lawmaker who took part in the protest and who was hospitalized after being hit by a tear-gas canister. The lawmaker, Sırrı Süreyya Önder, is Turkish, not Kurdish. (He is a member of the Kurdish Party.)
Geert Wilders Lauds Legal Project
Latest Blog Posts
Latest LP in the Media